Is "The Mentalist" a Blatant Ripoff of "Psych?"

  • By admin
  • October 14, 2019
  • 0


That is the query that crept into my head upon first listening to of CBS’s “The Mentalist.” Being an enormous fan of “Psych,” I used to be, after all, just a little irritated on the apparent similarities between the 2 exhibits.

Each exhibits have an anti-authority, faux-psychic, hyper-observant man-child–Patrick Jane for Mentalist, Shawn Spencer for Psych–who makes use of his talents to assist the police clear up crimes. However…however…would not each present have a personality like this (my imagined response from the execs at CBS when offered with this similarity)?

There are some variations between the exhibits. “The Mentalist” is a drama that not solely solves a case in every episode, in addition they have a collection thread a few serial-killer named Crimson John. When Patrick Jane’s (Simon Baker) spouse and daughter are murdered by Crimson John, he decides to give up his job as a sleazy television-psychic and use his talents to assist the police. Though Patrick works with a staff of 4 different individuals, he’s predominately a loner with difficulties trusting others.

“Psych” is a comedy that solves one or two instances an episode, and has a penchant for popular culture references. When Shawn Spencer (James Roday) makes use of his ultra-attentive abilities to name in a number of tips about the police hot-line, he’s falsely accused of being a prison himself. Because the cops are unwilling to imagine he is merely an observant harmless, he decides to move himself off as psychic–and scores a kidnapping case inside minutes. Shawn can not stand to be alone and should at all times be accompanied by his greatest good friend and reluctant associate Burton ‘Gus’ Guster (Dule Hill).

Personally, I am a a lot greater fan of “Psych” than “The Mentalist.” “Psych” is a lot enjoyable to watch–with its crisp writing, unique premise and hilarious duo of Shawn and Gus–I am shocked there aren’t extra knock-offs.

Not that I am inferring “The Mentalist” is a blatant ripoff of “Psych”, or something. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *